| North East Premier League | Norton (2000-2006) |
| North Yorkshire and South Durham Premier League | Saltburn (2013-2014) |
| Hartlepool (2015) | |
| Thornaby (2018-2022) | |
| Miscellaneous | Norton (2004) |
| Durham University Community Elite XI (2005) | |
| Durham Cricket Club Elite XI (2005) | |
| Billingham Synthonia (2008) | |
| Hartlepool (2009-2010) | |
| Saltburn (2011-2012) | |
| Hartlepool Second XI (2015) | |
| Thornaby (2016) |