Teams Karen Plummer played for

Women's TestNew Zealand Women (1984-1991/92)
Women's ODINew Zealand Women (1981/82-1991/92)
Women's First-ClassNorth Shore Women (1967/68-1984/85)
 Auckland Women (1989/90-1991/92)
Women's List ANorth Shore Women (1981/82)
 Auckland Women (1987/88-1988/89)
Women's First-ClassNew Zealand Women (1984-1991/92)
Women's List ANew Zealand Women (1981/82-1991/92)
Women's World CupNew Zealand Women (1981/82)
Women's MiscellaneousSouth Auckland Women (1976/77)
 New Zealand Women (1981/82-1984)